Research Blog #9: Argument & Counter Argument



My argument for my paper is that:

Tourists are curious about the paranormal and want to investigate, so the tourist locations cater to this by making enjoyable and informative tourism destinations. The tourists tend to become more open to the paranormal and share their changed view with their peers, which leads to the peers touring for themselves and starting the cycle anew.


Robert Kruse argues differently in his journal, "Point Pleasant, West Virginia", where he discusses how tourism not only hides the "everyday-ness" of small towns like Point Pleasant, but also has a tendency to railroad a narrative of the area into a singular version as opposed to the nuances of life. 


Timothy & Olsen argue against it in Tourism, Religion and Spiritual Journeys, which was the topic of my third literature review, and claim that tourism is actually more beneficial then harmful. 

“...the economic impacts associated with religious tourism are greater than those associated with other market segments, because pilgrims and other religious travelers are avid buyers of religious souvenirs.” (Timothy 11)

Not to mention that while tourist locations do often focus more on one narrative over a plethora, some locations do invite tourists to reach their own conclusions by exploring the town and surrounding areas, such as both Point Pleasant and Roswell. Point Pleasant has a tour of the TNT Plant for tourists during festival season, and also has the Mothman Museum open year round where they explicitly say on their website to come and, "Research and uncover the truth for yourself." Roswell has a similar situation, where they have an extensive museum related to UFOs where visitors can explore and draw their own conclusions, and the museum also points towards other local business and locations where people can further investigate the legend and experience the town.


Kruse, II, Robert J. “Point Pleasant, West Virginia.” Southeastern Geographer, vol. 55, no. 3, Fall 2015, pp. 313–337. EBSCOhost, doi:10.1353/sgo.2015.0026.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Visual Aspect

Image
  NOTE: The original image found on the Mothman Festival website was pretty blurry, so I did take the liberty of sharpening the image somewhat. Otherwise, I did no other edits. In the image above, the camera has captured a view of the large crowd that is flooding the streets of Point Pleasent, West Virginia during one of their annual Mothman Festivals. Lining the sides of the streets are temporary stands for vendors that set up shop for the festival with a variety of festival and or Mothman-related paraphernalia. While I couldn't find any hard numbers about the number of visitors during the festival, estimates have placed at least around a thousand attendees during the festival, which is believable when looking at an image like this. This helps illustrate just how powerful and important paranormal tourism is and can be for a local economy.
Read more

Literature Review #4

Image
Source Citation: Terry, Neil et al. "Bikers, Aliens, And Movie Stars: Comparing The Economic Impact Of Special Events". Journal Of Business & Economics Research (JBER) , vol 7, no. 11, 2011. Clute Institute , doi:10.19030/jber.v7i11.2356. The article explains the history of three towns in brief detail as well as the origins of each town’s respective festival, though my main interest was in the UFO Festival of Roswell, New Mexico. In the section following these backgrounds, the authors compared some economics from the residents as well as the average economic stats of each festival, and then discussed some potential reasons behind the size and profit of each festival. The biggest draw of the article was the data on the profit of the UFO Festival, which I needed to help prove that paranormal tourism is a viable economic option. All three authors are professors in Economics/Finance at the West Texas A&M University in Canyon, Texas. Dr. Neil Terry is also a dean at the un
Read more

Topics Under Consideration

Image
 The topic I'm currently considering the most is the Mothman of Point Pleasent, though I'm sure I would end up talking about the reports of it from over the world. Mothman always interested me since my parents showed me the Mothman Prophecies movie growing up, which also likely got me interested in the unexplained in the first place. The mystery over what Mothman is has always been alluring. Is it a giant humanoid moth? An alien or divine being? Or is it a bird or a secret government experiment? What connection does it have to the mysterious Indrid Cold, who stopped several people on highways in the area and talked to them telepathically in the period prior to the Mothman?  Image Source: Title card for the Mothman episode on Monstrum , a PBS Youtube series on creatures of folklore from around the world, their inspirations, and their effect on society. I personally recommend the series. If Mothman turns out not the topic I wish to pursue, I would look into ghosts. More specific
Read more